Finding the best Elijah Craig barrel Proof Batch: what is the best Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Batch?

For bourbon enthusiasts, few releases generate as much excitement as Elijah Craig Barrel Proof (ECBP). Since its introduction in 2012, this cherished expression from Heaven Hill Distillery has earned Bourbon lovers hearts its place among the most sought-after American whiskeys. Heaven Hill releases these batches three times a year - January, May, and September. If you're new to the series, each batch name has four characters: the first (A, B, or C) shows which release of the year it is, followed by the month and year. In mid-2023, Heaven Hill announced they would remove ECBP's 12-year age statement, instead varying the age statement with each release to allow for greater blending freedom.  

We will be looking at the best Elijah Craig Barrel Proof batches so far, however we will be excluding Elijah Craig batches prior to 2016. There were 12 batches of Elijah Craig Barrel Proof released between 2012 and 2016 which were dubbed the “Pirate Bottles” due to their squat and rounded shape.  

 1. Elijah Craig barrel proof batch C923 

When Heaven Hill announced they would remove ECBP's standard 12-year age statement in 2023, some enthusiasts worried about the future of this beloved bourbon. However, the distillery had something spectacular in store. Released in September 2023, Batch C923 stands as perhaps the finest expression in the series' history, featuring an impressive 13-year, 7-month age statement, making it the oldest Elijah Craig Barrel Proof release to date. Bottled at a fairly punchy 133 proof- this batch particularly special because it manages to balance its age and proof beautifully. The nose opens with rich caramel and an interesting sangria-like fruitiness that's unique for bourbon. On the palate, you'll find complex dark fruits, while the finish brings classic barrel-proof notes of oak and molasses, with what I can only describe as a warm brownie note. Breaking Bourbon even awarded this batch, Whiskey of the Year in 2023. If you are going to try out any batch from the Elijah Craig Barrel Proof series, this would definitely be it. 

2. Elijah Craig barrel proof batch B517 

Released in May 2017 at 124.2 proof, Batch B517 marked a significant moment in the series' history. Proving that higher proof isn't always better. At 124.2 proof, it's actually one of the lower proof offerings in the ECBP lineup (third lowest in the first 25 releases). In my experience, the more seasoned bourbon drinkers often prefer these more approachable proof points, as they can allow for better flavor development without the overwhelming heat. On the nose this batch combines caramel, vanilla, oak, and chocolate, while the palate offers sweet caramel, chocolate, and toasted oak, finishing with smooth oak, bitter chocolate, and a hint of spice. Its more approachable strength, combined with exceptional flavor complexity, earned it Whiskey Advocate's prestigious Whiskey of the Year award for 2018, cementing its place as one of the top Elijah Craig Barrel Proof batches. 

3. Elijah Craig barrel proof batch B520 

B520 Released in May 2020 at 127.2 proof, B520 delivers an intricate array of flavors despite its relatively modest proof point. The nose hits you with buttered popcorn and baking spices, followed by dried ginger and butterscotch. What I find particularly interesting is how water transforms this one - add a few drops and you'll unlock brown sugar and orange peel notes that weren't immediately apparent. The barrel char is prominent but never overwhelms the other flavors. Expect a bittersweet character with strong tannic notes of scorched wood. One of the better batches in the series, definitely worth checking out.  

4. Elijah Craig barrel proof batch A120 

January 2020 brought us this 136.6 proof powerhouse, and what stands out to me is its remarkable balance at such a high proof. The nose gives you dark brown sugar and stewed blueberries, with an interesting orange caramel note developing over time. Despite the proof, it doesn't come across as harsh - instead, you get this wonderfully viscous mouthfeel. It delivers the exact qualities I look for in whiskey that many bourbons lack with a cigar-like, ashy taste that evokes a campfire experience, all without the high price of High West Bourbon. If you enjoy rich, full-bodied bourbons, this batch delivers in spades. 

5. Elijah Craig barrel proof batch B523 

At 124.2 proof and 11 years, 5 months old, this May 2023 release marked the first batch without the standard 12-year age statement. While some were skeptical about the younger age, I think this batch proves age isn't everything. It brings a brighter, livelier profile than we typically see from ECBP - think stewed apples, warm cinnamon, and vanilla on the nose, followed by golden raisins and honey graham crackers on the palate. The finish turns spicy with dry rye and black pepper notes that I particularly enjoy. 

6. Elijah Craig barrel proof batch C921 

The September 2021 release (120.2 proof) is one for the oak lovers. What fascinates me about this batch is how it reminds me of the old "Elijah Craig 12" age-stated Small Batch Bourbon. You get this wonderful musty aged oak funk on the nose, along with chewing tobacco and baking spices. While it might not be as memorable as B520, it offers something different that I think oak-forward bourbon fans will appreciate. 

7. Elijah Craig barrel proof batch C919 

This 136.8 proof release stands out for its complexity. The nose reminds me of browned butter and dried cherries, with a leathery quality that suggests significant age. What I love about this batch is its dynamic finish - you get waves of cherry and chocolate chips, followed by clove and cinnamon spice, ending with dark chocolate and black coffee notes. The texture is remarkably velvety, with tannins that grip your taste buds just right. 

Final Thoughts

In our opinion, these are the best Elijah Craig Barrel Proof batches- they all demonstrate how varied ECBP can be while maintaining its core character. Whether you prefer the higher proof releases or the more approachable ones, there's something here for every Elijah barrel proof bourbon fan. If we missed your favourite batch, be sure to let us know in the comments down below!